A metal fabrication shop does not sell a product, it sells a drawing. Every request for quotation arrives with a different drawing, a different material, a different quantity. The quote has to go out fast, or the customer calls a competitor. And the margin is decided right there: in an estimate put together on a Friday evening in a spreadsheet, with last year’s plate price and a “roughly right” bending time.
Generic ERP systems are built for repetitive products, with a fixed bill of materials and a stable routing. In make-to-drawing manufacturing, nothing is fixed. This guide is for owners, finance directors and production managers of SMEs with 20 to 200 employees (plate and structural fabrication, precision sheet metal, machining, welded assemblies). It describes the seven functions to demand from an ERP, gives a fictional worked example of job cost, a selection table, a checklist of demo questions and a 90-day rollout plan.
Why Standard ERP Falls Short in Make-to-Drawing Metalworking
Four realities of the trade break a standard configuration.
The product does not exist before the order. There is no catalogue item: the part is born from the customer’s drawing. An ERP that requires a complete item, bill of materials and routing before it can price anything forces you to create hundreds of records for quotes that will never be signed.
Material is a surface, not a quantity. You buy a 3,000 x 1,500 mm sheet, cut ten parts from it, and a remnant is left that you may or may not be able to reuse. The material cost of a part depends on nesting, not on net weight.
Part of the value is external. Surface treatment, painting, galvanising, non-destructive testing: the part leaves, comes back, and is sometimes rejected. The ERP has to track an operation that happens outside your shop.
Proof matters as much as the part. Material certificates, qualified welders, inspection records: without traceability, some parts simply cannot be sold.
These characteristics place the trade close to Engineer-to-Order. For the general framework, start with our guide to ERP for ETO manufacturers. Here, we go down to shop-floor level.
From Quote to Estimate: Variable BOMs, Material, Routings and Machine Time
A fabrication quote is built from four blocks: material (sheet, sections, tube, fasteners), in-house operations (laser cutting, punching, bending, welding, machining, assembly), external operations (treatment, painting, NDT) and ancillary costs (freight, packaging, quality file).
What the ERP must allow:
- A bill of materials and routing created on the fly inside the quote, attached to the job, without a heavy item-creation process. If the quote is signed, the structure becomes the production order with no re-keying.
- Configurable standard times: cutting speed by material and thickness, bending time by number of bends, welding time per metre of seam. The estimator adjusts; they do not reinvent.
- An up-to-date material price, per kilo or per sheet, with a validity date on the supplier price. Steel and stainless prices move, and a quote valid for 30 days must not rest on a six-month-old price.
- An hourly rate per work centre, separating the machine (laser, press brake) from the operator, so that a manual welding station and a machining centre are not charged at the same rate.
Fast Estimating and Reuse of Similar Jobs
The function that saves the most time is the smart copy of a past job. The estimator searches for a similar part (same family, same material, close dimensions), duplicates it, changes the dimensions and quantity, and the ERP recalculates material, time and cost. Two conditions make this work: jobs classified by part family, and actual times captured on the shop floor, not the times from the previous quote. Without feedback from actuals to estimating, you simply duplicate your mistakes.
Some vendors offer DXF or STEP file import to pre-calculate surface area, cutting length and number of bends. That is useful, but validate it on your real parts: ask for a demonstration with three of your own drawings, not the vendor’s.
Material Management: Cutting, Remnants, Sheet Stock and 3.1 Certificate Traceability
Material weighs heavily in the cost of a fabrication job, often as the largest item. Three points need careful handling.
Cutting and remnants. The ERP must manage a stock of full sheets and of identified remnants (dimensions, grade, thickness, heat number). When a remnant is big enough for a new job, it is offered before a new sheet is bought. Otherwise physical stock drifts from theoretical stock, and job material costs are wrong in both directions.
Stock units. The same material is handled in kilos, metres, sheets and m². The ERP must convert without error between purchasing, stocking and consumption units.
Material certificate traceability. In demanding sectors (structures, pressure equipment, rail, nuclear), the customer requires an inspection certificate 3.1 under EN 10204. This document is a certificate of compliance with the order that states the results of specific inspections, validated by an authorised representative of the manufacturer who is independent of the production department. On the shop floor, the consequence is concrete: you must be able to link every delivered part to the heat of the original sheet, and therefore to the certificate. The heat number must follow the material at goods receipt, at cutting (including on remnants) and through to the delivery file. Check that the ERP manages a lot or serial number per sheet, and that it attaches the certificate PDF to the lot record.
Subcontracting: Surface Treatment, Painting, Galvanising, NDT
Few shops do everything in-house. A part may go to the galvaniser, come back, go to the painter, then to a laboratory for non-destructive testing. Subcontracting orders are where general-purpose ERP systems are often weakest. For the general mechanics of the subject, see also our guide to subcontracting orders in SAP, Odoo and Sage X3.
What to require:
- A subcontracting order linked to the production order, with the external operation inserted in the routing at the right place: after welding, before assembly.
- Tracking of parts at the subcontractor. Stock held by a third party is still your stock and your responsibility. The ERP must show it separately.
- Lead times by supplier, and the lead time actually observed. A galvaniser quoted at 5 days who delivers in 12 must show up in your data, not in the workshop foreman’s memory.
- Inspection on return: quantities, appearance, treatment certificate or NDT report. A non-conforming part on return triggers a non-conformance, not just a stock movement.
- Costing: the cost of the service is added to the job at receipt, with the supplier invoice matched.
Shop Scheduling: Machine Load, Production Orders and Time Booking
In a make-to-drawing shop, the bottleneck changes from week to week: one week the press brake, the next the welding or the machining centre. A useful ERP shows the load per work centre (laser, punch, press brakes, welding stations, machining centres) over a horizon of a few weeks, and lets you move a production order with the mouse.
What to look at:
- Finite-capacity scheduling or, at the very least, a view of overload per work centre. The infinite capacity of standard MRP modules hides overloads until the day they blow up.
- Simple shop-floor booking, on a tablet or kiosk, per operation: start, finish, good quantity, scrap. If booking is cumbersome it will not be done, and job costs will be wrong. Many projects fail here, not in quote management.
- Prioritisation by promised delivery date, with an alert when a job slips, and the ability to show remaining work per job.
- A link with maintenance: a machine that is down must remove its capacity from the schedule. On this point, see our article on ERP and CMMS integration.
Quality and Compliance: EN 1090, ISO 3834, Inspection Files, Non-Conformances
For a welded-fabrication shop producing structural elements, the EN 1090 standard is unavoidable. It governs the execution of steel and aluminium structures. CE marking follows system 2+: the manufacturer controls its production (factory production control) and a notified body inspects and then surveils it. The execution classes (EXC1 to EXC4) set the level of requirement, and the same source notes that the class must derive from the technical specification. For welding, the quality requirements of ISO 3834 also apply. (If you supply the UK market, check the UKCA and UK-specific requirements with your certification body.)
For the ERP, this translates into precise functions, whatever class you target:
- An inspection file per job, bringing together material certificates, welder qualifications, welding procedure specifications, dimensional and visual inspection reports, and the declaration of performance.
- Welder qualification linked to work centres: the ERP alerts you when an operator whose qualification has expired is assigned to an operation that requires it.
- Non-conformances and corrective actions, attached to the job, the part and the work centre, with their cost (rework, scrap) charged to job cost.
- Hold points: an inspection operation that blocks the next operation until it is signed off.
An ERP does not obtain your certification for you. It lets you produce the evidence without spending hours on it. If your quality approach runs through a full management system, see our guide to ERP and QMS integration for ISO 9001. Always check the exact requirements in the normative text and with your certification body.
Actual Job Cost: Quoted vs. Actual
This is the reason the whole setup exists. The actual cost of a job adds up:
- material consumed (including lost remnants), at actual receipt cost;
- hours booked per work centre, valued at the centre’s rate;
- subcontracting actually invoiced;
- quality costs: rework, scrap, additional inspections;
- ancillary costs (freight, packaging, specific tooling).
Fictional Worked Example
The example below is fictional, meant to illustrate the variance mechanism. A job of 50 welded steel brackets, sold for €24,000.
| Item | Quoted | Actual | Variance |
|---|---|---|---|
| Material (sheet, sections) | €7,200 | €8,100 | +€900 |
| Cutting and bending | €3,000 | €3,300 | +€300 |
| Welding and assembly | €4,500 | €6,300 | +€1,800 |
| Galvanising (subcontracting) | €2,400 | €2,400 | €0 |
| Inspection and rework | €600 | €1,100 | +€500 |
| Total job cost | €17,700 | €21,200 | +€3,500 |
| Margin on €24,000 | €6,300 (26%) | €2,800 (12%) | -€3,500 |
Without an ERP, this customer looks “profitable” in the annual accounts, because the margin loss gets diluted. With job-level tracking, you see three causes: a higher scrap rate than planned (material), a welding time underestimated by 40% (welding) and unquoted rework. That is exactly the reading that lets you adjust the standard times for the next quote and close the loop between actuals and estimating.
For it to be reliable, three prerequisites: regular time booking, subcontracting invoices matched to the job, and jobs closed properly (no job left open for two years).
Selection Criteria and Pitfalls
| Criterion | What you should see | Common pitfall |
|---|---|---|
| Drawing-based estimating | Quote with BOM and routing created on the fly, job copy | Item creation mandatory before the quote |
| Material | Remnants, sheet stock, heat number, 3.1 certificate attached | Stock in kilos only |
| Subcontracting | Subcontracting order, stock at third party, inspection on return | Subcontracting treated as a simple purchase |
| Scheduling | Load per work centre, finite or visual capacity, quick rescheduling | Frozen schedule, no link with time booking |
| Time booking | Tablet or kiosk, operation by operation | Entry deferred to the end of the week |
| Quality | Inspection file, qualifications, non-conformances | Documents outside the ERP, in shared folders |
| Job cost | Quoted vs. actual variance per job and per work centre | Cost calculated only at year end |
| Total cost | Licences, integrator, training, enhancements | Entry-level price without custom development |
Three Vendor Profiles to Examine
Without promising performance, here are three families to put in competition. Check each function with a demonstration on your own drawings.
- Vertical ERP systems built for job shops and make-to-order manufacturers. This is the profile closest to your vocabulary (jobs, quotes, subcontracting, time booking). Our comparison of Sylob, Divalto and Clipper details this family from a French market angle; in the UK and Germany, equivalent specialist vendors exist and should be on your shortlist.
- Odoo with metalworking modules or extensions. Flexible and modular, it can cover production management, but drawing-based estimating, remnants or heat-number tracking often depend on third-party modules or custom development. Have the vendor show exactly what is standard and what is custom.
- Microsoft Dynamics 365 Business Central with industry extensions. A solid base in finance and supply chain, completed by partner applications for make-to-drawing manufacturing. The issue is the quality of the extension chosen and the integrator’s ability to maintain it.
For an SME under 50 people, a lightweight vertical ERP is often enough. Beyond that, or with subsidiaries and consolidation requirements, the second and third profiles start to make sense.
The Risk of Over-Configuration
The classic trap: trying to model every special case from day one. The result is a project that drags on, operators who work around the tool, and quoting that is slower than before. Rule of thumb: start with a limited number of work centres, part families and standard routings, and enrich after three months of use.
Ten Questions to Ask in the Demo
- Show a quote created from one of our drawings, without creating an item first.
- How do you duplicate a similar job, and what gets recalculated?
- How do you manage a sheet remnant, from creation to reuse?
- How do the 3.1 certificate and heat number follow the part through to delivery?
- Show a subcontracting order with a partial return and a rejected part.
- How do we see the press brake overload over four weeks?
- How many clicks to book an operation on a tablet?
- How is the inspection file handled for a job subject to EN 1090?
- Where do we read the quoted vs. actual variance, by work centre, at job close?
- What custom development is needed for our case, and at what cost?
A Realistic 90-Day Rollout Plan
This plan targets a tight scope for an SME: one site, one shop, a few critical work centres. Timelines grow with data migration and interfaces.
- Days 1 to 20: scoping and data. Choose 5 to 10 part families, list work centres and their rates, clean up item and supplier files, define the scope. Appoint a lead on the shop floor, not only on the management side.
- Days 21 to 45: configuration and quoting. Standard routings, standard times, material prices, quote templates. First real quotes run in parallel with the old tool.
- Days 46 to 70: production and time booking. Launch of production orders, tablet booking on one or two work centres, subcontracting orders, material receipt with heat number.
- Days 71 to 90: cutover and measurement. Extension to all work centres, first job closures, first quoted vs. actual variance dashboard. Review with the teams and a list of adjustments.
A project like this does not stop at 90 days: you then stabilise for several months, notably on the quality of standard times. Our post go-live stabilisation checklist helps you frame this phase.
Going Further
Before launching a vendor consultation, download our ERP selection checklist to structure your requirements. If your shop also makes plastic parts or moulds, read our analysis of ERP for plastics injection moulding and cost per part, which applies the same actual-cost logic to another trade.